Fred Rogers was such an eccentric figure that the only way to approach him in a movie is to explore his effect on the people around him, as a kind of near mystical guru, a spiritual zenmaster of sorts. The same thing was more or less done in the documentary Would You Be My Neighbor, and now director Marielle Heller takes things to a surreal level in A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood, by focusing on the story of Mr. Rogers’s influence on one man, Lloyd Vogel (Mathew Rhys). Vogel is an investigative journalist for Esquire magazine known for hit pieces on his subjects, and Fred Rogers is the only person willing to talk to him for a “heroes” profile. He’s a man with longstanding anger towards his father (Chris Cooper), who abandoned him in childhood, and just being around Mr. Rogers for the article, being absorbed into his world of total and unique kindness, eventually has an eerily profound effect on him. The movie takes place in 1998 (based on the Esquire cover story by Tom Junod) and is framed as an episode of Mr. Rogers’s iconic children’s program, complete with dream sequences and transition scenes set in the make believe world of the neighborhood. This experiment has a hit and miss effect, but what makes the movie work is Tom Hanks’s performance as Fred, who drops all his own mannerisms to completely embody the living, breathing, gentle nature of Mr. Rogers. When he’s on screen he’s captivating, even though his character remains shrouded behind a cloud of mystery, as no one can really pierce the authenticity of the man himself. But Tom Hanks makes him larger than life, and you believe the oddness of his supremely gentle, yet overwhelming influence on others in his vicinity. It’s a strange movie at times, but a stirring one.
FROZEN II * 1/2 (Dir. Jennifer Lee and Chris Buck)